At long last, clarity on whether you can transfer your water rights

Because of the ample rain that has fallen countrywide, many dams are full, leading to cases where people do not have use for their water rights. So, it begs the question as to whether it is possible to sell your water rights to someone else?

Water use in South Africa is regulated mainly in terms of the National Water Act, 36 of 1998 (Act). In 2020, the North Gauteng High Court ruled that section 25 of the Act did not permit the sale or transfer of water use entitlement to your neighbour or any other person.

This decision was recently taken on appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA). In its judgment, the SCA found that a holder of an entitlement to use water, could surrender their entitlement to enable a third party to apply for a licence and receive compensation in return. 

The SCA acknowledged that section 25(2) of the Act created a mechanism for the permanent transfer of water use entitlements, allowing for one party (the entitlement-holder) to conditionally surrender his entitlement, while the other party (the prospective entitlement-holder) applies for the licence. However, if the relevant authority does not approve the licence application, the surrender is not enforceable. In doing so, the SCA confirmed that you can in fact transfer water use entitlements. 

About whether people could ‘trade’ in water, the SCA’s view was that a person could do anything that the law does not forbid and that water use entitlements could be traded. That said, the SCA did point out that the prospective entitlement-holder would still need approval for a licence in terms of the Act and that this approval by the licensing authority would hinge on the requirements of the Act. 

Should you wish to sell or transfer your water use entitlements, it will be important to take note of this judgment and make sure that your own contract and conditions align with the above requirements and includes requiring the buyer to obtain the necessary licence approvals as well. 

February 8, 2022
Section 8C explained: Tax tips for employee share schemes

Section 8C explained: Tax tips for employee share schemes

Employee share schemes are often introduced to reward, retain, or align employees with long-term business growth. However, under section 8C of the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 (the “Income Tax Act”), these arrangements can create significant and unexpected tax liabilities for employees when equity instruments vest. This article explains how section 8C operates, what qualifies as an “equity instrument,” and why careful structuring of share schemes is essential to avoid punitive tax outcomes.

The costly consequences of backdated share transactions

The costly consequences of backdated share transactions

The South African legislative framework regards backdated shares as a suspicious and illegal practice, as it arises when a share issue or transfer is recorded as having occurred on an earlier date than the actual transaction. While backdating may be viewed as an administrative oversight, the consequences may constitute compliance risk, serious misconduct on directors, beneficial owners and compliance officers who authorise the backdating of share transactions. This is because backdated shares may manipulate the timing of funds, obscure the source of funds, and distort a company’s beneficial ownership structure.

Tax transparency matters: Are your deals reportable?

Tax transparency matters: Are your deals reportable?

Some deals come with hidden reporting duties. Find out when your transactions could trigger SARS disclosure rules, and how to stay compliant. You may have heard the term “reportable arrangement” in tax conversations around commercial transactions. It sounds technical, and it is, but at its core, it’s about transparency. The South African Revenue Service (“SARS”) seeks information on certain transactions that could be used to avoid or reduce tax. If you enter a reportable arrangement, you may be legally required to report it. Failure to comply can result in significant penalties.

Sign up to our newsletter

Pin It on Pinterest